Integrating Retrieval Practice into classroom instruction

Retrieval practice is one of the most effective methods of learning and remembering information for long-term use. During retrieval practice, students “retrieve” what they know about a topic or lesson out of their memory. Retrieval practice requires effort on the part of the student to recall specific information, which is beneficial to improving learning and strengthening students’ memory. Retrieval practice can be “…a no-stakes learning opportunity that increases student performance, beyond formative and summative assessments” (Agarwal & Bain, 2019, p.4).

In general, giving students multiple opportunities for practice and retrieval will break up a lecture with short brain breaks and prove valuable in the effective learning process. If we can work these methods into our instruction and teach students how to use them on their own, our students stand a much better chance of actually remembering our material (Gonzalez).

Effective Learning and Studying Strategies Examples adapted from ASEE:

Spaced practice and interleaving

  • Spaced practice: Study material over longer, spaced intervals instead of cramming. For example, review material a day after class and then again a few days later, and so on.

  • Interleaving: Mix your practice of different subjects or skills together. For instance, instead of doing all your math problems in one go, mix problems from different chapters to improve your ability to switch between concepts. 

Jot Recall (Oakley, et al., 2021, p. 12-13)

  • Students check understanding of concept by recalling information without aids.

  • Promotes retrieval and spaced repetition to reinforce long-term memory.

  • Can be used in class or out of class as a study technique.

  • Pause and have students use a blank piece of paper to recall concepts by writing notes or making a drawing

  • Have students compare and discuss within a small group

Retrieval practice and elaboration

  • Retrieval practice: Actively recall information from memory rather than just rereading notes. This can be done by testing yourself with practice questions or by explaining concepts aloud in your own words.

  • Elaboration: Expand on new information by asking questions and connecting it to what you already know. For example, relate new theories to real-life situations or stories. 

Notetaking (Oakley, et al., 2021, pp. 25, 30-31)

  • Students are offered handouts or outlines of lecture materials to assist with notetaking.

  • Helps students actively engage with class material, instead of struggling to make sense of content and take notes at the same time.

  • Provides better studying references.

Scaffolding (Alber, 2011 and “Scaffolding,” n.d.)

  • Students move incrementally (via ‘scaffolds’) towards a deeper understanding of material.

  • Allows students to gradually build understanding.

  • Consider that students come to your classroom with varying backgrounds, experiences, and abilities.

Varied Practice (Oakley,, et al., 2021, p. 7)

  • Incorporating opportunities for students to practice what they’re learning in different ways and contexts.

  • Helps students consolidate material.

  • Aids long-term memory.

Other effective strategies

  • Dual coding: Combine words with visuals. Create concept maps, diagrams, or sketches to represent information, which can lead to a deeper understanding.

  • Concrete examples: Think of specific examples and non-examples to clarify the meaning of a concept.

  • Teach others: Explaining a concept to someone else is a powerful way to solidify your own understanding.

  • Elaboration: Students take the time to ask themselves complex and open-ended questions about the content they are learning or studying. This improves learning and goes beyond simple recall of information.

Incorporating metacognitive practices into your class

Dr. Sandra McGuire https://faculty.lsu.edu/smcgui1/ is an expert in supporting faculty in helping students learn how to learn in their class. She argues that most students come to college underprepared. Specifically, she advocates for metacognitive equity, or closing the gap between students who use metacognition (effective thinking and learning strategies) and those who do not. (https://digital.library.txst.edu/server/api/core/bitstreams/0516466a-bf01-4aff-a0ba-9c326f59d464/content). She argues that this the gap in metacognitive strategies contributes most to the persistent achievement gap and that all students must be taught how to learn. A 2017 Hechinger Report https://hechingerreport.org/colleges-enroll-students-arent-prepared-higher-education/, shares “data from 911 two- and four-year colleges revealed that 96 percent of schools enrolled students who required remediation in the 2014-15 academic year, the most comprehensive recent numbers. At least 209 schools placed more than half of incoming students in at least one remedial course”. 

Dr. McGuire counseled several students to have a back-up plan for medical school after failing an organic chemistry test in her course. She went through faculty professional development which encouraged her to incorporate metacognitive learning strategies into her teaching practice. The improvement she saw in students helped her come to the belief that most students do not know how to learn. She argues that in many cases, metacognitive learning was not a prerequisite for good grades in their previous educational experiences. “Many received As and Bs without the need to learn the subject matter in a great deal of depth”.  An example she shares to illustrate this point is supporting a student who stated he had “valedictorian syndrome””, which he explained by stating, “Well, I was valedictorian of my high school class but I’m flunking everything at [college].” 

If you think of these same students as scientists, she argues, “They’ve collected, interpreted and made predictions regarding data they have collected for all of their lives! If they skipped classes or barely opened their textbooks in previous educational experiences, yet successfully graduated in a top percentage of their class and ended up in college, we can understand that based on their personal “lab” experience, the same behaviors should result in the same success in college.”

This led her to the conclusion: It is often not a student’s lack of innate ability or talent, but rather a lack of effective learning strategies, that can make the difference in academic success. (Growth mindset)

What are the benefits of using metacognitive strategies in your classroom?

When instructors assist students to develop strong metacognitive abilities, students develop a deeper awareness of the learning process and gain control over their own learning. This leads to:

  • enhanced personal capacity for self-regulation

  • increased ability to manage one’s own motivation

  • students becoming more independent learners.

 

Examples of metacognitive strategies you can incorporate into your course:

From Cornell University: 


https://teaching.cornell.edu/teaching-resources/teaching-cornell-guide/teaching-strategies/metacognitive-strategies-how-people

  • Use a pre-class survey, homework assignment, polling questions in class, or a short reflective writing piece as a way for students to explore their existing knowledge about a topic.

  • Ask students to prepare for class by reviewing the week’s syllabus topic and reading. Use the Canvas online quiz tool, in-class polling, or index cards to learn how students understand the goals for the class meeting, how they think they should prepare, and what they learned from the reading.

    • Some potential questions:

      • What is one question you still have about the reading?

      • What is one thing you are curious about?

      • How can you best prepare for class?

      • What can you do in class to help yourself learn?

 

Additional strategies include: 

  • Verbalize the thought processes used to consider, analyze and solve problems. This may be as simple as ‘thinking aloud’.

  • Encourage students to ask themselves the following while studying or completing homework assignments:

    • What should I do first?

    • Is something confusing me?

    • Could I explain this to someone else?

    • Do I need help to understand this?

    • Where did I go wrong?

    • Does this relate to other situations or prior knowledge?

    • How can I do it better?

 

In Teach Students How to Learn: Strategies You Can Incorporate Into Any Course to Improve Student Metacognition, Study Skills, and Motivation (p. 85) (Available at IU libraries https://iucat.iu.edu/catalog/18412847Dr. McGuire provides details on how you can incorporate the following practices in your course:

  1. Previewing

  2. Preparing for active reading

  3. Paraphrasing

  4. Reading actively

  5. Using the textbook even if it is not required

  6. Going to class and taking notes by hand

  7. Doing homework without using solved examples as a guide

  8. Teaching material to a real or imagined audience

  9. Working in pairs or groups

  10. Creating practice exams